This is more than likely related to the ongoing AWS outage, but E-Verify is also experiencing issues when creating new cases.
These include:
1. Multiple cases needing to be created to report as intended
2. A "check back later" status on the case, once created
Based on what we see, these cases should sync as intended once the underlying issues are resolved, so please let the case(s) process for now. If there are any other questions or concerns, please submit an incident.